Salutaris

While internet myths continue to warn that soy “feminises men,” “fuels cancer,” or “disrupts the thyroid,” high-quality human trials and large population studies strongly disagree. In fact, regular soy intake is consistently associated with better heart health, improved cancer survival outcomes, and longer health-span — especially in populations such as Okinawan Japanese, Singaporeans, and traditional Korean communities, where daily soy intake is normal and chronic disease rates are remarkably low.

Below is what science — not wellness gossip — actually tells us.

The top myths about soy — and why they’re incorrect

“Soy lowers testosterone or causes fertility issues in men.”

Human meta-analyses show no reduction in testosterone, sperm quality, muscle mass or virility from normal soy intake. This myth originates from rodent studies using extreme dosing, not real-world nutrition.

“Soy raises estrogen or increases breast cancer risk.”

Soy isoflavones are not hormone estrogen — they are selective estrogen receptor modulators (SERMs) which often have the opposite effect. Among over 11,000 breast cancer survivors across pooled human studies, women who consumed more soy had lower recurrence and higher survival.

“Soy harms the thyroid.”

Only an issue if someone is iodine-deficient — which is already a health risk regardless of soy. In iodine-sufficient humans, soy does not impair thyroid function. However, if someone takes thyroid medication (levothyroxine), they should space soy several hours apart, just as with calcium or iron supplements.

The strongest clinically backed benefits of soy

Heart protection — Meta-analyses of randomised human trials show soy can reduce LDL (“bad”) cholesterol by 3–5%, particularly when it replaces animal protein. Whole soy foods deliver fibre, potassium and antioxidants too.

Lower cancer mortality — Soy intake is linked to significantly reduced breast cancer recurrence and improved survival. Emerging evidence for prostate protection is positive but less settled.

Anti-inflammatory & metabolic support — Population data show lower rates of type 2 diabetes and metabolic syndrome where soy is consumed daily.

Higher longevity / health-span — Okinawa (Japan), where residents average 1–2 servings of soy daily, historically held the highest life expectancy and lowest dementia and cardiovascular disease rates globally. Similar patterns exist in Singapore and South Korea.

How much soy should most people aim for?

Evidence-based, safe, and beneficial daily intake:

Goal	Target amount
General health & longevity	1–2 servings/day
Cholesterol / heart health improvement	25 g soy protein/day (≈2–3 servings)
Cancer survivorship (per cohort data)	≥1 serving/day linked to better outcomes

One serving ≈
• 100 g firm tofu
• ½ cup cooked edamame
• 1 cup unsweetened soymilk
• 80–100 g tempeh
• 1 Tbsp natto or miso (fermented = additional gut benefits)

Whole, minimally processed forms are best — tofu, natto, tempeh, edamame, unsweetened soymilk, traditional miso soups.

What to avoid or be extra mindful about

Avoid / Caution	Reason
High-dose isoflavone supplements (>100 mg/day)	Food is safe — mega-dosing isolates is not well studied long-term
Highly processed “soy imitation meats”	Some are ultra-processed, high in sodium, oils, additives
Taking thyroid medication at same time as soy	Just space apart by 3–4 hours to avoid absorption issues
Soy formula for preterm infants	Not recommended — but safe for full-term infants when medically appropriate

Cultures that prove soy is a longevity food, not a liability

• Okinawa, Japan — among the longest-living people on earth; soy is consumed daily since childhood, often as tofu and miso broth at breakfast.
• Singaporean Chinese adults — high tofu and soy milk intake linked to lower stroke and heart disease risk in population data.
• Traditional Korean diets — fermented soy (doenjang, cheonggukjang) contributes to gut health and cardiometabolic protection.

Across these populations, soy replaces animal saturated fat, supports gut and hormone balance, and promotes healthy aging without the disease burden seen in Western countries.

Bottom line — soy is not the problem. In many cases, it’s part of the solution.

For most adults, 1–2 servings of whole soy daily, or 25 g soy protein/day when actively pursuing heart health, is a clinically supported and safe nutritional strategy.

Far from being hormonally disruptive, soy foods are consistently linked to better cardiovascular markers, improved cancer outcomes, and exceptional health-span in the world’s longest-living populations.

As with all dietary interventions, consult your qualified dietitian if you have any related health concerns. It is recommended that introducing new foods to your diet be done gradually and, as always, get in-tune with your body and listen to what it tells you.

Image by Freepik